Six indicators, a pair for each tone: one indeterminate, one determinate. Open a set to try its moving prototypes, then see how they got there.
Research
Started with loading as a topic rather than with sketches, because determinate and indeterminate is not a style choice. It is a claim about what the system knows.
How long is the wait
The threshold picks the type. One catch: hold the indicator back about half a second past the limit, because flashing a spinner at work that finishes quickly makes the interface feel slower. Knowing when not to appear is part of the job.
Determinate or indeterminate
Determinate
Claims
This much is done
Use when
The system can count, past 10 s
Must
Track the real thing, never reassure
Screen reader
role="progressbar" plus live aria-valuenow
Indeterminate
Claims
Something is happening, length unknown
Use when
Short waits, or nothing countable
Must
Never stall
Screen reader
Same role, aria-valuenow left out
As soon as progress becomes knowable, an indicator should move from the right column to the left. Direction is fixed too: linear runs leading edge to trailing, circular starts at the top and turns clockwise.
Why the same wait feels different
Motion direction is a lever, not decoration
Backwards ribbing that decelerates cut perceived duration about 11 percent. Harrison and others, 2010.
Step granularity is a tone control
More, smaller steps read as faster; fewer, larger steps stretch the wait. Ziat and others, 2022.
Trust the direction, not the 30 percent figure
A skeleton previews the layout, a spinner spotlights the delay. Repeated everywhere, no controlled study.
Rules the tone has to survive
Keep moving
A frozen loader reads as a frozen app.
Stay proportional
Small update, small indicator.
Speak plainly
“Saving changes”, not “API request pending”.
Offer a way out
Cancel on long work, when it is safe.
Do not block
Let background work run and report back.
Never motion alone
Status needs text, and has to park under reduced motion.
Pattern survey
Sixteen existing patterns on one shared clock, so the same real duration can be compared across forms. The last group separates form from placement: a button state and an inline state are the same shapes put somewhere specific.
Live demo. Interact with it here or view it larger.
At 10 seconds the numeric readout is the most precise and the least bearable, because there is nothing to watch between updates. The segmented bar at 20 steps feels quicker than the smooth bar over an identical duration, exactly as the study predicts.
Into the designs
Both halves of a set share a tone, not a shape. A bar squeezed into a circle is not the same indicator.
Granularity, easing, and direction are where tone lives, and critique can argue with all three.
Each set needs a named context, because an indicator has no tone without something to be the tone of.
Status text is part of the design. Three tones should produce three different sentences.
Process
Next: three tones, named with their contexts, then sketches before any code.
Ideation
Loose sketches before the three tones are picked. Each one runs live in its box.
Ball chainA circle sweeps under fifteen hanging chains; only the ones it touches sway.Bar and ballA circle slides end to end along a thin bar.StarEight rays; a circle runs out and back on each in turn, so the pulse goes round.EdgeThe screen edge is the bar, filling clockwise while the number counts.RallyA ball rallied at you down the middle, then out to the left and right.GlowOne box slowly brightens and fades, like a light breathing.HourglassAn hourglass of grains; only the falling stream moves.WashColour washes across the whole screen from the left.Wash, ripplingThe same wash, its front swaying like water.TapA film still in grey dots; only a finger taps, on and on.StairwellAfter In the Mood for Love: a figure climbs into a red gap, step-printed. View it larger for the controls.CorridorA box's back wall draws away into a long hall; its depth is the progress.GustA spinner of particles shaped like a gust of wind.ReedsRows of tall bars ripple on slow sideways waves.Reeds, flatReeds pressed flat: split lines draw one rolling wave.BounceOne ball bouncing in place, stretching and squashing.Rose trailA comet of dots runs round a breathing seven-petal rose.Ripple dotsA halftone ring whose dots swell outward in waves.EclipseA dark disc with a shimmering, two-layer halo.TwistStrands of light wind into a rope round a turning ring, then unwind.VortexStreaks of light whirl round a black sphere.BloomThousands of specks on a ball that crumples and opens like a flower.Line countLine fragments snap together to build the count, 1 to 100.CrackFour panels parted by two wandering cracks; at the end they fly apart.Brush ringA dry-brush circle turning one way, then the other.Brush halvesTwo dry-brush half circles at the edges, turning together.SpiralGrains settle into a spiral round a circle; the spiral is the progress.CoilGrains wind round a tumbling hoop; the wrapped share is the progress.HatchTwo layers of slanted, stepped bars; the grey they leave open swells and shrinks, and where they overlap it goes black.HalftoneBoxes of halftone dots come up one by one from the right until the page is black.PhasesFour white circles swing back and forth round a diamond, swelling and shrinking a quarter turn apart.Ping-pongA glowing turn runs along a row of dot pairs and back; three at a time draw in on a smooth curve and join with lines.