Week 03

Selectors

Oct 5, 2026 selectors switches checkboxes radio-buttons research spec micro-motion tone

Deliverables

Twelve components, four sets of one switch, one checkbox and one radio button. Open a set to try its prototypes, each a labelled list with its spec, then see how they got there.

Set 1Luxurious

Prototypes

Switch Sleep environment, on frosted glass in a dusk-lit room. Turned on, the glass thumb glides across on a spring with no bounce and turns solid cream, and the track fills with warm lamplight. Off undoes it quickly.
Checkbox Wind-down. Each box is frosted glass; ticked, warm lamplight fills it from the centre and a fine umber check is drawn across it.
Radio buttons Wake me with. Frosted glass rings; the chosen one takes a small cream dot of lamplight and its ring warms, the one before lets go quickly.

Process

How the set got here, one tried version at a time, the last one now.

Switch

Luxurious switch, step 1
First pass, after Cleo: an espresso gradient on warm paper lit by a peach glow, a pearl handle, fine lines, a slow spring with no bounce.
Luxurious switch, step 2
Maison: ivory stationery, a Didone serif, a pearl on a gold hairline rail. Then depth from one light, and the glints taken out as cheap.
Luxurious switch, step 3
Calm glass, after a warm sleep-room reference: a dusk-brown room, frosted glass, lamplight for on. The glass made clearer, the thumb smaller when off.
Luxurious switch, step 4
On a shallow arc: a glass band for the thumb to ride along (rebuilt). The thumb sat off the band, so the band went.
Luxurious switch, step 5
The route alone: one 3px line shows the way; a glass bead travels it and grows into a solid cream thumb, lamplight drawn behind.

Checkbox

Luxurious checkbox, step 1
First pass: a soft square in one fine line; ticked, a peach bloom and an espresso fill with a fine check.
Luxurious checkbox, step 2
Maison: a stone setting stood on its point, champagne satin set into it, an engraved check.
Luxurious checkbox, step 3
Calm glass: a frosted square that fills with warm lamplight, a fine umber check drawn over it.

Radio buttons

Luxurious radio buttons, step 1
First pass: a fine ring; chosen, a gradient pearl swells from the centre and a soft light stays around it.
Luxurious radio buttons, step 2
Maison: a gold ring that takes a pearl, a second fine ring around it like a setting; the pearl later larger and matte.
Luxurious radio buttons, step 3
Calm glass: frosted rings, the chosen one holding a small cream dot of lamplight.
Set 2Quirky

Prototypes

Switch Playback settings. Off, the track and handle are pen scribbles that go round and round and never stop boiling. On, the handle hops across in six drawn frames, winding up, smearing long, overshooting squashed and landing with a colour-split flash, and both cut into neon shards on black, with halftone, a colour-split edge and spray; the shards keep changing colour while it stays on. The row turns with it: a rough black band slams in behind, and the label goes neon with a colour-split edge.
Checkbox Toppings. Off, a box scribbled round three times with a stray loop at its corner, boiling. Ticked, it swells past its size with a pink and cyan split, springs back, and is neon shards on black with a fat yellow check on top, re-coloured four times a second. Unticking drops it back to ink in three. The row turns with it: a rough black band slams in behind, and the label goes neon with a colour-split edge.
Radio buttons Ringtone. Each option is a tangle of circles with a spiral inside and loops flung around it, after the ink reference. The chosen one swells past its size and springs back as neon shards with a yellow dot, spray where the loops were; the one before drops back to ink. The row turns with it: a rough black band slams in behind, and the label goes neon with a colour-split edge.

Process

How the set got here, one tried version at a time, the last one now.

Switch

Quirky switch, step 1
First pass: ink scribbled round and round on grey paper, never still; on, the handle jumps across and both cut to neon shards (rebuilt without the row change that came next).
Quirky switch, step 2
The row turns too: a rough black band slams in and the label goes neon. The hop drawn in six held frames, slowed so each can be seen.
Quirky switch, step 3
Off outlines as dry-brush strands that bunch into one band in places and float apart in others, the clumps drifting round.

Checkbox

Quirky checkbox, step 1
First pass: a scribbled box with a stray loop; ticked, neon shards and a fat yellow check (rebuilt without the row change).
Quirky checkbox, step 2
The row turns with it, and ticking swells the box past its size with a colour split before it springs back.
Quirky checkbox, step 3
The empty box drawn in brush strands that bunch and float apart.

Radio buttons

Quirky radio buttons, step 1
First pass: tangled ink circles with loops flung around; the chosen one in neon shards with a yellow dot (rebuilt without the row change).
Quirky radio buttons, step 2
The row turns too, and the chosen one swells and springs back.
Quirky radio buttons, step 3
Each ring drawn in brush strands that bunch and float apart.
Set 3Mysterious

Prototypes

Switch Privacy settings in the dark. The handle is a moon: off, a new moon with only its rim showing. Switched on, it crosses at once; after a short hush its shadow slides off the other way, the track takes a thin light and the row surfaces in light. Off, the dark takes it back quickly. The pointer carries a small light. In black and white; and anything you switch on may, a few seconds later, be quietly undone in a burst of red static, as if it never took.
Checkbox Who can find me. Each box is the dim outline of a light bulb hanging in the dark. Ticked, a hush, then it comes on like a failing bulb, the check inside the glass, stuttering before it holds, as if a light had found something that was always there; the row and its label surface with it. In black and white; and anything you switch on may, a few seconds later, be quietly undone in a burst of red static, as if it never took.
Radio buttons Messages vanish after. Each dot is a moon in eclipse, so only the dim ring shows. Choose one: a hush, then the shadow slides off, a crescent widening to full, the ring lights and the row surfaces. The one before goes back into eclipse at once. In black and white; and anything you switch on may, a few seconds later, be quietly undone in a burst of red static, as if it never took.

Process

How the set got here, one tried version at a time, the last one now.

Switch

Mysterious switch, step 1
Black and white, words and controls in mist; the handle a moon that comes out of eclipse. Now and then a setting is quietly undone in a burst of grey static. The earlier moonlit-blue and red-static steps were not kept as frames.

Checkbox

Mysterious checkbox, step 1
Light opens from the centre of the box, the check already in it.
Mysterious checkbox, step 2
Too smooth: it now comes on like a failing bulb. Tried as a glowing filament check in a dark box.
Mysterious checkbox, step 3
Back to the filled light, the box now a bulb hanging base-up.

Radio buttons

Mysterious radio buttons, step 1
Each dot a moon in eclipse; chosen, its shadow slides off and the ring lights.
Set 4Playful

Prototypes

Switch Party mode. The handle is a pinwheel of four pastel blades. Switched, it rolls across on a bouncy spring, a little too far and back, spinning a turn and a quarter like a pinwheel catching the wind; the track fills pink to peach. Pressed, it squashes.
Checkbox Pick your sweets. Ticked, the box swells like a balloon, faster and faster, blushing pink, then pops: it snaps small, eight coloured lines burst out past its edge, the fill and a white check are there, and it wobbles back to size. Unticked, it lets its air out: it sputters side to side, the fill shrinks away and the check is flicked off.
Radio buttons Balloon colour. Each dot is a soap bubble; choose another and the bubble travels over from the one chosen before, sliding home on a bouncy spring, stretching on the way and squashing as it lands, with a ripple spreading from the ring.

Process

How the set got here, one tried version at a time, the last one now.

Switch

Playful switch, step 1
First pass: a beach ball that rolls across, its panels spinning while its shine stays put (rebuilt).
Playful switch, step 2
The roll without the beach ball: a soft knob with one swoosh and a sprinkle (rebuilt).
Playful switch, step 3
A pinwheel: it rolls across on a bouncy spring and spins a turn and a quarter.
Playful switch, step 4
Jelly: bigger and gummy, with a light top edge and a lip below. Pressed it squashes, let go it wobbles; the pinwheel rolls as before.

Checkbox

Playful checkbox, step 1
Swells like a balloon and pops, eight coloured lines bursting out past its edge.
Playful checkbox, step 2
Jelly: a bigger gummy box. The pop now squashes flat and wobbles back; unticking lets the air out, sputtering, the fill shrinking away and the check flicked off.

Radio buttons

Playful radio buttons, step 1
A soap-bubble dot. Later it travels over from the one chosen before, stretching on the way and squashing as it lands (a change in motion; the end state looks the same).
Playful radio buttons, step 2
Jelly: a bigger gummy ring and bubble that squash when pressed and wobble when chosen.

Brief

Twelve components: four sets, each one switch, one checkbox and one radio button, each set expressing a tone. Tones can repeat across sets. Every design has to do its job. Each one gets a working prototype, with the versions tried along the way shown as its process.

Every component sits in a list, each row with a text label, the way the brief's examples do: a settings row with a switch, a list of meal extras with checkboxes, a language picker with radio buttons.

What each prototype has to show

In a list ofMust show
SwitchLabelled setting rowsOff → on, and on → off
CheckboxLabelled options, any number chosenOff → on, and on → off
Radio buttonsLabelled options, one chosenOff → on, and on → off

The spec

No Figma file this week: every prototype carries its own spec, in a section of the prototype page. At least spacing, font, font size and line height, the component's size, and every other property that shapes it, such as roundness and stroke width. The numbers are read from the same values the prototype runs on, so the spec cannot drift from the design.

Research

All three say yes or no to something. What differs is how many answers a list allows, and when the answer counts.

Read mainly against Apple's Toggles guidelines and Material 3's switch, checkbox and radio button pages, every tab of each: overview, specs, guidelines, accessibility. IBM's Carbon, one of the open systems on Design Systems' public list, is a third voice. Where they agree, it is a rule. Where they differ, it is room for a tone.

Three selectors

handle track slides off → on
Switch
Pick it when
A standalone setting that should act now
Chooses
One setting, on or off
Counts
At once, no Save button
In a list
Every row stands alone
Keyboard
Tab to it, Space flips it
Screen reader
role="switch" with aria-checked: “Wi-Fi, switch, on”
off on mixed (a parent only)
Checkbox
Pick it when
Several related options, or a parent with sub-choices
Chooses
Any number from a list, none included
Counts
Often only once the form is sent
In a list
Rows are independent; a parent row can be mixed
Keyboard
Tab from box to box, Space ticks it
Screen reader
Native input type="checkbox": “Pickles, checkbox, checked”
only one
Radio buttons
Pick it when
One answer from two to five, all in view
Chooses
Exactly one from a set
Counts
Choosing one clears the one before; you cannot go back to none
In a list
The rows are one group
Keyboard
Tab into the group, arrow keys move and choose
Screen reader
radiogroup of radios: “English, radio button, 1 of 3, selected”

Which one, and where

Apple's guidelines say less about drawing these controls than about choosing between them, and Material agrees on almost every point. The choice decides the list each prototype sits in.

A switch lives in a list row

The row's own words are its label. Outside a list, iOS uses a button that changes its background instead, and macOS keeps switches out of toolbars.

Weight follows what it controls

A switch is heavier than a checkbox, so it suits a setting that matters or one that turns on a group. On the Mac, a regular switch leads and mini switches follow.

Settings with children are checkboxes

Checkboxes line up on their leading edge and indent to show what depends on what. A parent whose children disagree shows a dash, the mixed state.

Two to five, then a menu

Radio buttons come in sets of two to about five. Past that, the list swallows the screen. Both systems draw the line at five and switch to a menu.

One on/off is a checkbox

A tick reads faster than a lone dot. Use a pair of radio buttons only when each state needs its own name.

Side by side, evenly

Laid out in a row, every radio button gets the width of the longest label, so the gaps never wobble. Material would rather they were never in a row at all.

Switch, up close

Material draws the switch in dp, the numbers below. The on state is told twice: the handle crosses the track and it grows from 16 to 24 dp, so colour is never the only signal.

52 32 1 2 3 4 5
  1. Track52 × 32 dp, fully round. Off: a 2 dp outline and no fill.
  2. Handle16 dp off, 24 dp on, 28 dp while pressed. Always 24 when it carries an icon.
  3. Icon, optional16 dp. It has to mean on or off: a check and an X, never a moon or a pencil.
  4. State layerA 40 dp circle behind the handle on hover, focus and press.
  5. Target48 dp. Denser layouts may shrink it only when people ask for them.
Off16 dp handle
On24 dp handle
Hovered40 dp layer
FocusedRing outside
Pressed28 dp handle
DisabledFaded, no layer
DoStack standalone settings, one switch per row, on a settings screen.
DoIf the handle carries an icon, it says on or off: an X and a check.
Don'tUse icons that don't answer on or off, like a moon or a pencil.
Don'tWrite words inside the track. At that size they are too small to read; use an icon.
Don'tSwitch between two opposing things, like list or map view. That is a choice; use a connected button group.
Don'tUse switches for options that wait for Save. Switches act at once; these are checkboxes.
SwitchHow it behaves
LabelInline and short, naming what the switch does when it is on. The label keeps its colour in both states.
EffectAt once, no Save. If it waits, it is not a switch.
KeyboardTab lands on the handle; Space or Enter flips it.
Screen readerReads the label, then “switch”. A vague label like “Photo album” gets a fuller accessible name: “Photo album access”.
Touch and pointerTap or drag grows the handle; hover grows the layer. The control shows it noticed before it changes.

Checkbox, up close

The smallest of the three, and the only one with a third state. Material 3 added indeterminate and error versions of every state.

18 1 2 3 4
  1. Container18 dp square, 2 dp corners, a 2 dp outline when empty.
  2. Icon18 dp, centred: a check for on, a dash for mixed.
  3. State layerA 40 dp circle on hover, focus and press.
  4. Target48 dp, and the label belongs to it: clicking the words ticks the box.
UnselectedOutline only
SelectedFill and check
IndeterminateA parent, split
Hovered40 dp layer
ErrorFor every state
DisabledFaded
DoGive a list a parent checkbox. Ticking it ticks every child; some ticked makes it a dash, and ticking the dash ticks all.
Don'tUse switches for a list of related options. Checkboxes say the items belong together, and take less room.
Don'tFade the label of an empty box. The text keeps its colour whether ticked or not; the box carries the state.
CheckboxHow it behaves
LabelOn the trailing side, scannable. In an editable checklist the box may stand alone.
GroupIf the set's relation isn't obvious, a heading introduces it, its baseline lined up with the first box.
EffectUsually when the form is sent. When a single box turns something on or off, it acts at once.
KeyboardTab to each box, Space ticks it. Material's own checkbox key table is copied from its chips page, so the WAI-ARIA pattern is the one to follow here.
Screen readerReads the label, then “checkbox, checked”. The accessible name is usually the visible label.

Radio buttons, up close

A radio button never stands alone: the group is the component. Each option needs its own label, because each is a different answer.

20 1 2 3 4
  1. Ring20 dp icon, drawn with a 2 dp stroke.
  2. Dot10 dp, only in the chosen one.
  3. State layerA 40 dp circle on hover, focus and press.
  4. Target48 dp, label included: the words choose too.
UnselectedEmpty ring
SelectedRing and dot
Hovered40 dp layer
FocusedRing outside
PressedLayer and dot
DisabledFaded
DoStack the options in a column, with one already chosen.
Don'tNest radio buttons under one another, or let a group take more than one answer. That is a checkbox job.
DoGive a way out. Once chosen, a group can't be cleared, so offer “None” or a Clear button.
Radio buttonsHow they behave
LabelEvery option has its own, after the circle. The group's title names the group.
How manyTwo to five. More than that, and a drop-down saves room, at the cost of an extra tap and more thought.
EffectAt once, unless the group sits in a dialog or page that is saved.
KeyboardTab enters at the chosen one, or the first if none (Shift+Tab: the last). Arrows move and choose, wrapping from last to first. Space chooses and never clears.
Screen readerA “radio group” named by its title; each option read by its label.
Three systems side by side
PartMaterial 3AppleCarbon
Switch52 × 32 dp51 × 31 pt on iOS; regular and mini on Mac48 × 24 px; small 32 × 16 px
Switch handle16 / 24 / 28 dpKnob stretches while held18 px; small 10 px
Switch on colourPrimaryGreen, or the app accent if it contrastsSuccess green
Checkbox18 dp, 2 dp corners, 2 dp outlineSmall square, title trailing16 px, 2 px corners, 1 px outline
Checkbox statesUnselected, selected, indeterminate, each with errorOff, on, mixedUnchecked, checked, indeterminate
Radio button20 dp ring, 2 dp strokeSmall circle, label after18 px ring, 1 px stroke
Target48 dp44 pt—

Where Apple and Material disagree

Mostly they say the same thing. Where they part, the brief has to pick a side, and the choice is written into every prototype's spec.

QuestionAppleMaterial 3What I follow
Radio buttons in a row?Fine, spaced by the longest labelAvoid horizontal listsStacked: the brief puts every control in a list anyway
A group with nothing chosen?Not addressedGuidelines: always preselect. Accessibility: may start empty, with a way outPreselect, and add “None” when skipping is a real answer
Where the switch's label livesThe row's own content on iOS; a label on MacAlways an inline label, never text in the trackThe row label, nothing written on the control
Switch colourGreen by default; change it only if neededThe theme's primary colourColour is a tone lever, as long as on stands clear of off
How on is told apartFill, shape or inner mark, never colour alonePosition and a bigger handle, optional iconTwo signals at least, one of them not colour
Mixed stateCheckboxes; radio can, but rarely shouldCheckbox only, plus error statesOnly a parent checkbox
Keys that flip a switchSpace (platform default)Space or EnterBoth

How each one moves

Material 3's own code, read for what moves, for how long and on which curve. Click a row to play it: each bar underneath fills on that part’s own curve, on one shared 0–500 ms clock.

Live demo. Click a row, then click it again; switch the speed at the top.
Table view
PartDurationCurve
Switch handle, position300 msOvershoot, cubic-bezier(0.175, 0.885, 0.32, 1.275)
Switch handle, size250 msStandard, cubic-bezier(0.2, 0, 0, 1)
Switch handle, pressed100 msLinear
Switch handle, colour67 msLinear
Checkbox, checking (box and mark)350 msEmphasized decelerate, cubic-bezier(0.05, 0.7, 0.1, 1)
Checkbox, unchecking150 msEmphasized accelerate, cubic-bezier(0.3, 0, 0.8, 0.15)
Radio, inner dot grows300 msEmphasized decelerate
Radio, dot out and ring colour50 msLinear

What the motion teaches

Arrive slow, leave fast

Turning on eases into place and earns a look; turning off hurries away. Material's checkbox leaves in under half the time it arrives.

Travel says which way

The switch handle crosses the track, so where it ends is the answer. A small overshoot makes it feel thrown rather than placed.

Answer the press, not only the release

Held down, Material's handle swells to 28 in 100 ms; iOS stretches its knob into a pill. The control shows it felt the finger before anything changes.

Grow from where it lives

The radio dot swells out of the ring's centre; the checkbox fill pops up from 60%. Nothing slides in from somewhere else.

Colour cuts, shape moves

Colour changes in 50 to 67 ms, almost instantly. The time is spent on shape and position, which is where the eye follows the change.

Follow the finger

On iOS the knob can be dragged, and a spring picks up the finger's speed where the drag ends. With reduced motion on, the end states alone still have to read.

Speed is a tone, too

Carbon draws the same switch with the opposite temper. Its handle and track colour move together in 70 ms on an exit curve, with no overshoot: the switch is simply already there. Material spends 300 ms and lets the handle overshoot. Same job, two characters, so duration and curve belong to the tone, not only to the spec.

Switch handleDurationCurveReads as
Material 3300 msOvershoot, cubic-bezier(0.175, 0.885, 0.32, 1.275)Thrown, springy
Carbon70 msExit productive, cubic-bezier(0.2, 0, 1, 0.9)Instant, matter-of-fact
Apple, iOSSpringCarries the finger's speed after a dragPhysical, held

Rules the tone has to survive

The whole row is the target

Clicking the words flips the control too. Material draws an 18 dp box inside a 48 dp target: the drawing can be tiny, the hit area cannot.

The label stays put

“Wi-Fi” stays “Wi-Fi” whether it is on or off. The control carries the state; rewriting the words as it flips only makes people read twice.

Never colour alone

On and off must differ in shape or position too. Apple names three ways: add or remove a fill, show or hide a shape, change the mark inside. WCAG 1.4.1.

Edges you can see

The outline of an empty box or ring needs 3:1 contrast against what is behind it, off state included. WCAG 1.4.11. A new accent colour has to stand clear of the off state too.

A switch acts now

Flip it and the thing is already on. If a choice waits for Submit, it is a checkbox, not a switch.

One group, one stop

Tab lands on the chosen radio once; the arrow keys move the choice. Start with one chosen, or the group can never return to none.

When a row needs help

On the Mac a tooltip, which Apple calls a help tag, appears when the pointer rests on a control; in visionOS, when the eyes do. Touch has no hover, so on a phone the same sentence lives under the label instead. Atlassian suggests a tooltip to say what flipping a toggle will do, which is where week 2's tooltips meet these rows.

Explain the one being pointed at

Describe only the control the person is asking about, not its neighbours and not the bigger task around it.

Start with a verb, skip the name

Say what the control does, as an action: “Pause background updates”. The label already says “Low Data Mode”; repeating it wastes the space.

Sixty to seventy-five characters

A fragment, no articles. If a control needs more than that to explain, Apple's advice is to simplify the control, not lengthen the tip.

Sentence case, no full stop

Sentence case reads as plain speech. Leave off the closing full stop unless the rest of the product uses one.

Change with the state

A selector has two states, so its tip can have two sentences: each says what flipping it now will do.

Teach the strange by motion

Don't explain how a standard switch works. If a tone makes the control unfamiliar, orient people with animation, not a paragraph.

The row around it

The brief puts every control in a labelled list, so the row is part of the spec too. A baseline to depart from: a tone can move every number here, as long as the rules above still hold.

PartSizeSource
List row, one line56 dp tall, 16 dp side paddingMaterial 3 lists
Row label16 sp on a 24 sp lineMaterial 3, Body Large
Label colourOn surface, the same in every stateMaterial 3
Touch target48 × 48 dpMaterial 3
Touch target44 × 44 ptApple
Target, the minimum24 × 24 CSS pxWCAG 2.5.8

Process

Ideation

Loose sketches, each running live in its box.