Oct 26, 2026menussystemshortcutsubmenuresearchspectone
Deliverables
Two sets of menus, each a tone. Each set has the menu system, every item configuration from one build, and the menu in use: sections, a submenu, and every item answering hover and press. Open a set to try its prototypes, each with its spec, then see how they got there.
Brief
Two sets of menus, each expressing a tone. Tones can repeat. Every design has to do its job. Each one gets a drawing and a working prototype.
Tone is the soft attribute: the personality, the associations, the attitude. Function is the hard one: what the menu is for and what it lets you do. A menu's function is to offer a short list of commands, let you pick one, and get out of the way, so the tone has to live in how the items look, answer the pointer and open, without slowing the pick.
The rule that shapes everything: the menu item works as a system. One basic structure, many configurations.
What the structure has to take
Part
Has to support
Label
A single line of text
Left
An icon, or nothing
Right
An icon, a keyboard shortcut, or a badge
Grouping
Sections, with a divider or a section label
Depth
A submenu that opens from an item
States
Shows
Enabled
The item at rest, ready to pick
Hover
The item under the pointer, about to be picked
Pressed
The pick landing
The brief shows two drawings. Apple's: a dark menu on a warm gradient, three items with shortcuts right-aligned, a divider, and a Submenu item whose highlighted row opens a second menu beside it, Item X lit in red. Material's: one item build measured out, items 48 tall with 2 between, an icon and label, a trailing shortcut, a section label 32 tall, corners of 16 on the menu and 12 on the active item.
The spec
As before, no Figma file: every prototype carries its own spec in a section of the page. At least spacing, font, font size and line height, the size of the menu and its items, and every other property that shapes it: roundness, stroke width, shadow, the state layers, how the submenu opens. The numbers are read from the values the prototype runs on, so the spec cannot drift from the design.
Research
What a menu item is and how it behaves, from Apple's Menus and Material 3's Menus. Nothing about tone yet, only the menu.
The parts
One container, one item build. Only the container and the label are required.
ContainerThe menu; as wide as its longest item
Left iconOptional; the same column in every item
LabelThe one required text; one line, a verb
RightA shortcut, a badge, an icon, or a submenu chevron
DividerSplits the menu into groups
Section labelNames a group; not pickable
One build, many items
Each side has a few options. Mixing them gives every item the menu needs, from one build.
Left: nothing or an icon
When one item has an icon, the labels still start on one line.
Right: shortcut, icon, badge, chevron
One at a time. The chevron means the item opens a submenu.
Grouping: dividers and sections
Related commands sit together; a label names the group when it needs one.
Try it
A plain menu with no tone, doing everything the brief asks. Point at an item, press it, or use the arrow keys; Sort by opens its submenu to the side.
Mail
HoverA layer of the text colour, about 8%
PressedThe same layer, about 12%
⌘ShortcutRight-aligned, muted, in Apple's order ⌃ ⌥ ⇧ ⌘
›SubmenuOpens beside its item on hover, click or →; ← or Esc closes it
RUnavailableDimmed, still in its place, not pickable
Three states
The keyboard's highlight looks the same as hover: in a menu, whichever item is lit is the one Return will pick.
EnabledAt restHoverLayer, about 8%; also the keyboard's highlightPressedLayer about 12%, then the menu closes
Do and don't
DoRight-align shortcuts in one column so they read as a list of their own.DoGroup related commands and split the groups with a divider.DoDim a command that can't be used now; don't hide it.Don'tNest submenus in submenus; past one level, commands get lost.Don'tGive a submenu item a shortcut too; it opens, it doesn't do.Don'tLet labels jump left where an item has no icon; keep the icon column.
Process
Ideation
Loose sketches, each running live in its box, each with every part the brief asks for.
TerminalType only. Hover inverts, pressing blinks.LetterpressA printed card. Hover rolls ink, pressing bites in.ReceiptThermal paper. Hover highlights, pressing stamps OK.RadialA ring around the pointer. Sections are arcs.GlassFrosted glass. The lit pill glides between items.KeycapsShortcuts as real keys that go down on press.Index cardsEach section a card, its name the tab.ElevatorA call panel. Pressing lights the button.Label makerEmbossed tape. The tape colour is the section.NotchThe tab bar’s middle button is the menu; it rises out of the scoop.SidebarA tree that opens in place; folded to a rail, it flies out.SlantItems step down a diagonal; the submenu opens past the orange rule.Action ringWedges round a centre; the submenu is an outer ring.FanArcs fanning from a core; each level is the next ring out.HorizonItems stand on an arc; sections ride the rail above.HUDA cyan frame; hover fills the row like a meter.ToolbarAn insert menu you can rearrange by its grips.InspectorA dropdown that writes its preset into the panel.ColumnsThe submenu is the pane’s second column.NodesA lit item shows a port, like a socket for a wire.Big typeOnly type: the word Menu set huge, the items large beside it.StaircaseEach item a step down and right; its number is its key.WiresPointing at an item wires it to everything it will change.FlashlightThe pointer is a torch; only what it lights is clear.VHSA paused tape’s on-screen menu over static.Spirit boardThe planchette drifts to your item, a beat late.Save roomA typewriter types each item again as you point.