Nov 2, 2026toolbarssystemalignmentbuttonsresearchspectone
Deliverables
Two sets of toolbars, each a tone. Each set is one prototype: the toolbar in use, moving between left, center and right and between icon, text and icon and text buttons, then every configuration laid out in enabled, hover and pressed, then the spec.
Brief
Two sets of toolbars, each expressing a tone. Tones can repeat. Every design has to do its job. Each one gets a drawing and a working prototype.
Tone is the soft attribute: the personality, the associations, the attitude. Function is the hard one: what the toolbar is for and what it lets you do. A toolbar's function is to keep the few commands you use most within one reach of the content they act on, and to stay out of the content's way, so the tone has to live in how the bar sits, how its buttons look and how they answer the pointer, without hiding what each one does.
The rule that shapes everything: the toolbar works as a system. One basic structure, many configurations.
What the structure has to take
Part
Has to support
Alignment
Left or right aligned, and center aligned
Icon button
An icon alone
Text button
A label alone
Icon and text button
An icon with its label
States
Shows
Enabled
The button at rest, ready to press
Hover
The button under the pointer, about to be pressed
Pressed
The press landing
The brief shows two drawings. Apple's: the top of an iPad window, its toolbar split into three groups. Leading holds a back button and the title; center holds six tool icons in one capsule; trailing holds undo, share and more in a capsule, then compose on its own. Material's: a floating toolbar measured out, 64 tall, 8 of padding at each end, four buttons 4 apart; beside it, 8 away, a 56 primary action with its own rounded square.
The spec
As before, no Figma file: every prototype carries its own spec in a section of the page. At least spacing, font, font size and line height, the size of the bar and its buttons, and every other property that shapes it: roundness, stroke width, shadow, the state layers, how it changes between alignments. The numbers are read from the values the prototype runs on, so the spec cannot drift from the design.
Research
What a toolbar is and how it behaves, from Apple's Toolbars and Material 3's Toolbars. Nothing about tone yet, only the toolbar.
The parts
One container, one button build. A primary action can stand beside the bar.
ContainerThe bar; as wide as its buttons, never the full screen when it floats
Button48 square for an icon; wider for a label; the one build
State layerCovers the button on hover and press
Icon or labelAn icon, a label, or both, side by side
Primary actionOptional; the one most used command, beside the bar
One build, many toolbars
Where the bar sits and what its buttons hold are two separate choices. Mixing them gives every toolbar the brief asks for, from one build.
Left or right
The bar holds an edge, next to the content or the hand it serves.
Center
The bar sits on the middle line; it grows out to both sides when it gains a button.
Icon, text, or both
Same button, same height. Only its width changes with what it holds.
Try it
A plain toolbar with no tone, doing everything the brief asks. Move it to a side, change what its buttons hold, then point at a button and press it. Tab lands on the bar once; the arrow keys move along it.
⇥TabLands on the bar once, on the last button used
←ArrowsMove along the bar; Home and End jump to its ends
●ToggleA tool stays on, tinted, until pressed again
Three states
A tool that stays on (Draw, say) is a fourth look, not a fourth state: it still answers hover and press on top of being on.
EnabledAt restHoverLayer about 8%, on one button onlyPressedLayer about 12%, the command runs
Numbers to remember
64Height of Material's floating toolbar in the brief's drawing.
48 · 44ptSmallest button target, Material / Apple. An icon is 24 inside it.
8 · 4Padding at each end of the bar, and the gap between buttons.
56The primary action beside the bar, 8 away from it.
Do and don't
DoGroup buttons that work together, and space the groups apart.DoUse short verbs; when the bar runs out of room, put the rest in More.DoShow a tool that stays on with a tint, so the bar says which mode you are in.Don'tFit every command in; a crowded bar shrinks targets and hides the important few.Don'tMix icon, text and both in one group; pick one kind per group.Don'tUse a toolbar as tabs; it acts on what is shown, it doesn't switch views.
Process
Ideation
Loose sketches, each running live in its box, each with every part the brief asks for: icon, text, and icon and text buttons in three states, and an align switch at the bottom right that moves the toolbar left, center or right. The first five come from one Touch Bar reference, split by the kind of row. Each has its own motion as well as its own look.
Strip: TypeThe text row of a Touch Bar. The T tool stays on in white; font and weight are text keys whose rows hold the choices; alignment is an icon key whose row holds icon and text keys; size is a scrubber.Strip: InsertA label, then keys for each kind of thing to insert. Symbols opens icon-and-text keys, and those open a shelf of components that lift white when pressed.Strip: SwatchesThe keys are the colours: round, no key behind them. They grow on hover, squeeze on press, and the picked one wears a ring. Spectrum swaps the row for a slider.Strip: TransformTransform, Align and Boolean each open a labelled row of coloured icon keys, and the rows stack under the strip so all three can stay out.Strip: ScrubRotate, Scale and Width are text keys; the picked one turns the strip into a ruler you drag under a fixed red mark. Nine dots open the transform points.FolderA 3D tool’s settings with folder tabs for a toolbar: the open tab takes the panel’s colour and runs into it, and each tab brings its own colour.ClinicA patient record in warm greys: icon-and-text pills on a dark band with one soft curve, a round filter, text pills that switch records on and off, a yellow add button.KeyframeAn animation inspector on a yellow page: monospace values in dark cells you drag to scrub, green for what is live, magenta for the field being edited, a transport over a timeline.PaletteA drawing app’s tool palette in three eras (1990 one-bit, 2000 bevels, 2024 dark). Changing era turns every tool over in a wave and walks it to its new place; held tools fly out their hidden siblings.CollageA mid-90s paths palette over a loud collage. Everything moves in steps like an old screen: anchors land in three frames, Stroke runs a plotter pen, Fill fades through dither, the close box rolls the palette up like a shade.GraphA visual-scripting editor. Play sends a bead of light from node to node while data wires stream into the node it reaches; Pause freezes it mid-wire. Chips drop new variables in; the layout and tilt buttons move the graph on springs.BlueprintA tower builder’s plan with a dark icon-over-label panel. Mirroring is shown, not told: a placed column snaps to the grid and its copies fly across the axes; Undo pulls them home; Construct stacks the floors one by one.BezelA phone whose black edge swells into the screen when a side button is pressed: a volume slider, a silent switch, a wheel of focus modes. The bulge is liquid: height leads, width follows, and it drains back after two seconds.PadsA live-visuals strip of effect pads. Everything keeps time: the dial steps, the tempo kicks, steps light, radars sweep once a bar. Hit a pad or its key and its colour washes out from the hit; TAP counts the tempo in.JamA whiteboard toolbar of objects: the pencil rises out of the bar, sticky notes swing with your drag and land with a squash, shapes jiggle and pop onto the board, the “New shapes!” tab bobs until opened.RecorderA screen recorder’s pill bar. Modes light the screen, Cam sends a bubble to the corner, Mic’s levels move; Record counts 3, 2, 1 on the button, then the whole bar gathers into a small pill with a breathing dot.FiltersA white filter pill over a flat for rent. A grey spot follows the pointer; a filter grows the pill down into its panel; values roll from “Any”, the home count counts, and Clear swells out only when there is something to clear.SparkA round assistant button with a count. One shape throughout: the circle stretches into a bar of actions, the badge riding its edge; a result card rises and the badge pops; closing draws the bar back into the circle.NodeA dark automation card whose toolbar rises from behind its top edge. The avatars fan open and “+3” becomes three more faces; Run sends light round the border before a tick pops in; Duplicate slides a copy out behind.