Nov 16, 2026navigationsidebartab barsystemresearchspectone
Deliverables
Two sets of navigation, each a tone. Each set is one prototype: a vertical sidebar that expands and collapses and a horizontal tab bar, both in use, then every state, then the spec.
Brief
Two sets of navigation, each expressing a tone. Tones can repeat. Every design has to do its job. Each one gets a drawing and a working prototype.
Tone is the soft attribute: the personality, the associations, the attitude. Function is the hard one: what the navigation is for and what it lets you do. Navigation's function is to show where you are, where else you can go, and to take you there in one move. So the tone has to live in the surface, the marks and the way an item answers the pointer, while the current place still reads at a glance.
Each set has two kinds of navigation, built on one structure.
Two kinds
Kind
Also called
Has to
Vertical
Navigation rail, navigation drawer, sidebar
Expand and collapse
Horizontal
Tab bar, navigation bar
Hold the top destinations in one row
What the structure has to take
Part
Has to support
Icon and text
Every item has an icon with its label
Category headers
A heading over a group of items
Trailing slot
A place on the right of an item that holds a badge, an icon or text
States
Shows
Enabled
The item at rest, ready to go to
Hover
The item under the pointer, about to be picked
Pressed
The press landing
Selected
The place you are now
The spec
As before, no Figma file: every prototype carries its own spec in a section of the page. At least spacing, font, font size and line height, the size of the sidebar (expanded and collapsed), the tab bar and each item, and every other property that shapes them: roundness, stroke width, icon size, the selected indicator, the badge. The numbers are read from the values the prototype runs on, so the spec cannot drift from the design.
Research
What navigation is and how it behaves, from Apple's Sidebars and Tab bars, Material 3's navigation bar, rail and drawer, and three desktop systems (Microsoft Fluent, IBM Carbon, GitHub Primer). Nothing about tone yet, only the navigation. The full report, with every source, is in the research report.
One thing to know first: the two guides speak differently. Material publishes every number. Apple's iOS 26 pages dropped their size tables and now describe behaviour (a floating glass bar, a bar that shrinks on scroll); the old sizes survive only in 2024 copies. Where a number below is Apple's, it says which.
The parts
A sidebar is a list of places, grouped under headers. Each place is one row: an icon, a label, and a slot on the right. The row you are on is held in a pill.
ContainerThe panel; Material's drawer is 360 wide, the expanded rail 220–360
Category headerNames a group; muted, never pressable. Material: Title small
Active indicatorThe pill behind the place you are; 56 tall, 12 in from each side
Icon24; tinted when picked. Apple prefers filled symbols
LabelOne or two words; the place's name
Trailing slotA badge, an icon or text: counts, a new mark, a link out
DividerOptional; space or a hairline between groups
Two directions, one list
The same places, laid out three ways depending on room. Wide windows get the sidebar; it collapses to a rail of icons; on a phone the list turns into a bar across the bottom. Headers only fit in the widest one.
Sidebar · expanded
Icon and label side by side, headers, trailing slots. Material: expanded rail or drawer, 220–360 wide. Fluent shows it at 1008 px and wider.
Rail · collapsed
Icons alone (or icon over a small label). Material: 96 wide (80 before Expressive), up to 7 places. Headers become space; counts become a dot.
Bar · compact
Icon over label, across the bottom. Material: 80 tall (64 in Expressive), 3–5 places, the icon held in a 56 × 32 pill.
Apple · floating glass
iOS 26: the bar floats over content on Liquid Glass and shrinks while you scroll down. Search can sit apart as its own round button at the end.
Bar · wide
On windows 600 and wider, Material Expressive turns each item sideways: icon beside label in a 40 tall pill. Apple does the same in regular width.
One list, two layouts
Apple's iPad tab view can turn into a sidebar and back; Material swaps bar, rail and drawer by window width. Same places, same order.
The slot on the right
The brief asks for a slot at the end of each row that holds one of three things. Primer splits them by job: something to read (a count, an icon that says where the link goes) or something to press (an action, which then needs its own name).
Badge
Something new or waiting. Material: a 6 dot, or a 16 tall badge with a number, in the error colour. Apple keeps the red badge for what really matters.
Icon
Says where the row goes or what it holds: a link out of the app, a lock, a pin. If pressing the icon does something of its own, it is a button with its own label.
Text
A plain count or a short word, in the muted colour: Material's drawer puts Inbox's 24 here in the label's own size (Label large).
Try it
A sidebar and a tab bar that hold the same places. Collapse the sidebar, change what the slot holds, pick a place in either and watch the other follow.
HomeThe place picked in the sidebar or the tab bar.
⇥TabMoves through the places one by one: they are links, not a menu
⏎EnterGoes there; the picked one is marked aria-current="page"
◫ToggleThe round button at the top folds the sidebar; it says aria-expanded
Three choices in it, taken from the research. Collapsed, a place keeps its name for the pointer (a tooltip) and the screen reader, since NN/g found icons alone rarely speak for themselves. The tab bar has no room on the right, so the slot moves onto the icon's corner as a badge, the way both Apple and Material do it. The width eases open on Material's default spatial spring (damping 0.8, stiffness 380, about 500 ms) while the labels fade on the faster effects spring, so the words are gone before the panel narrows past them.
Four states
The same ladder as last week's buttons, on a row: a faint layer of the ink colour for hover and press, and selected is not a layer but the pill, which stays.
EnabledMuted ink, no containerHoverLayer 8% (Material); Apple: a glass highlightPressedLayer 10%, then the page changesSelectedThe pill and a tinted icon; stays until you leave
Carbon, IBM's system, adds a 4 px bar on the left edge of the selected row, so the place reads even without colour. Material's state layers sit only on the pill area, not the whole row width, in the bar and rail. Apple asks that tabs are never disabled or hidden: a place you can't go to yet should still open and explain why.
How it moves
Two schools. Material moves on springs, named by what they move: spatial ones for position and size (they may overshoot a little), effects ones for colour and opacity (never overshoot). Carbon moves its rail on a short curve: 110 ms and the labels simply appear.
Note that Material's pill does not slide from the old place to the new one; it fades and grows where you tapped, so the eye lands on the new place, not on the trip. Settle times are from sampling each spring with a mass of 1; the springs themselves are Google's.
Laws of UX that shape navigation
Hick's law
More choices, longer to decide. Keep the top level short (3–5 in a bar, about 7 in a rail) and push the rest down a level.
Fitts's law
Big, near targets are faster. Whole rows are the target, not just the label; screen edges help. At least 24 px (WCAG), 44 pt (Apple), 48 (Material).
Jakob's law
People expect your app to work like the others they use. Sidebar on the left, bar at the bottom of a phone, the picked place visibly marked.
Chunking · common region
A long list reads as a few short ones once headers and space split it. Things inside one boundary feel like one group.
Serial position
The first and last items are remembered best. Put the most-used place first and a key one last; Apple warns against burying critical items at a sidebar's bottom edge.
Von Restorff
The one that differs is the one remembered. Only the selected place gets the strong mark; badges stay rare so they still stand out.
And one finding to weigh against collapsing: NN/g's study of 179 people found hidden navigation was used about half as often as visible navigation on desktop (27% against 48%), and tasks took at least 39% longer. A collapsed rail is a cost the design has to earn.
Accessibility
Question
Answer
What is a sidebar, in code?
A <nav> of links. The current one carries aria-current="page". Tab moves between them. Not a menu.
And a tab bar?
If it moves to another page, the same: links in a <nav>. Only if it swaps a panel in place is it a tablist with aria-selected and arrow keys.
The collapse button?
A disclosure: aria-expanded and aria-controls pointing at the sidebar.
Collapsed, icons only?
Every item keeps a name for the screen reader and a tooltip for the pointer.
Selected look?
Not by colour alone: a pill, a bar or a weight change, at 3:1 against its background.
Motion?
Under reduced motion, snap instead of spring.
Numbers to remember
96 · 360Material's rail collapsed, and the widest expanded rail or drawer.
56 · 48Drawer row height; the smallest a touch target gets (Material).
80 · 64Navigation bar height, baseline and Expressive; its pill is 56 × 32.
3–5Places in a bottom bar; a collapsed rail holds up to 7.
6 · 16Badge: a dot, or a pill with a number.
8 · 10%Hover and pressed layers.
Do and don't
DoMark the current place clearly, and only that one.DoGive a collapsed rail's icons a tooltip and an accessible name.DoGroup with headers and space; keep headers quiet and unpressable.Don'tCrowd a bottom bar past five; move the rest into a More place or a sidebar.Don'tBadge everything; a badge on every row means none of them is news.Don'tGrey out or hide a place you can't use yet; open it and say why.
Process
Ideation
Loose sketches, each running live in its box, each from a reference, with every part the brief asks for: a sidebar that folds to a rail, a tab bar holding the same places, category headers, and a slot on the right. A switch at the bottom right (in View larger) folds the sidebar and changes the slot between badge, icon and text.
SequenceA chronophotograph pasted up on a board, eleven real photos of a skier's turn curving down the sheet (the user's own reference image). Each photo has a slot cut from the same image: at rest they show their own photo, but hovering along the path flips every slot to the next photo twelve times a second, so the turn plays like film, and the photo under the pointer lifts like a picked-up print. Each stretch of the path draws its button in beside it as a pencil loop with a handwritten name; the current one is circled in red crayon.HuntA treasure hunt. A grid of grey and white dots with fields of blue, cyan, red and yellow drifting through it, stirred round the pointer. The nav buttons are hidden in the dots, scattered; near the pointer each one develops pixel by pixel and dissolves again as you move away. Found buttons keep a faint trace, the current place stays developed with a blinking cursor, and Tab focus reveals them without a mouse.BleedA top nav bar with dropdowns on a chromatography sheet, drawn rough: blotchy dye bands, uneven rims, colour bleeding into the paper. The paths never change; every column is always there. Opening a menu only brings its column's detail back to life, band after band down the strip: the dye thickens, the rims sharpen, the labels surface. The rest sink back to faint stains. The picked item is a hollow ring.PrintA riso print on off-white paper: typewriter index, blocks of ink smeared sideways with scanlines, halftone edges and colour out of register. Each place has its own ink. Hover is a test print, a few dry streaks; press pushes the ink further and shifts the off-register layer; click runs every scanline out at its own speed into a full block as the layers line up. The old print lifts off and leaves a faint ghost.DotA grey capsule of words, the picked one white with a small dot under it. The dot stretches into a short dash as it travels, like a comet, then shrinks back and lands with a small bounce; the word it reaches brightens and grows a touch. Hover shows a faint ghost dot.WirePlaces are knobs on one wire on a black base; the picked knob turns blue and the wire round it lights up. An iridescent orb, the assistant, rides above the wire like a bead on a soft spring, stretching along its path and slowly turning its colours. In the sidebar the wire stands up beside the labels.CutA neon green frame around charcoal panels. The picked place is a slanted green cut through the dark bar; it slides on a spring and leans harder the faster it goes, the way the gutters lean in the reference, then stands back to its resting slant.SpreadWide capitals spread across a near-black card. Hover spreads a word's letters apart; picking brightens it, grows a short line from its centre, and slides the chapter number in from the side you came from. The sidebar is the same words down the left edge; folded, only the numbers stay.TickerA market summary: the black list of markets is the sidebar, with each day's change in the trailing slot, and the chips are the tab bar. A green bar sweeps in behind the picked row, the black chip slides along, and the big word rolls letter by letter between UP and DOWN as the arrow turns over and the panel turns green or red. Folded, only the short codes stay.WeightA soft white capsule with a heavy dark pill. The pill has mass: it stretches as it moves and overshoots as it stops, the bar leans the other way to counter it, and the labels ahead of it get pushed aside. Labels turn white exactly where the pill covers them, and the activity chips above swap one after another for the new place.InkA black-outlined capsule of capital words. The black pill moves like an inchworm: its front reaches the new word first, covering both for a moment, then its back end lets go and pulls in. Letters invert exactly where the ink passes, so a word can be half white mid-move.GlassMilky frosted glass with a blue gel for the picked place. Light travels through the glass: a glint runs along the rim from the old row to the new, the old gel drains, and the new one fills in from the rim and flashes. In the tab bar the two light lines travel apart, the top one quicker.DialAn activity list laid round an arc. Picking turns the whole dial until the place reaches the centre handle; names tilt with the curve and fade with distance, and the mouse wheel turns it one place at a time. The tab bar is the same dial lying on its side.NotchA white bar on magenta whose three ways of marking a place become the states: hover is an underline, press is a tinted square, selected is a notch cut into the edge with a dot in it. On a pick the notch slides along the edge to the new place, with the dot riding inside it at the same height.EdgeA white screen on a dotted grid in monospace capitals. The column of photo crops in the middle is the vertical navigation, with no separate sidebar: the picked crop opens from a circle into a large rounded square and the others shift to make room. Expanded, each name is typed in beside its crop; collapsed, only the crops stay. The tab bar is a scrubber line: the thumb slides to the picked stop and the count rolls its digits.SwellA square charcoal bar of thin icons; its edge swells into a hump under the place you are, and a circle in that place's own colour rides the crest. Picking sends the swell along like a wave: it flattens while it travels and swells back on arrival, the circle's colour blends from place to place, and the icons lift as the wave passes under them. Hover raises a small swell of its own. In the sidebar the same wave bulges out of the left edge.PillA navy capsule of outlined icons on lavender; the place you are is a white pill with a filled icon and its label. The pill travels on two springs, its leading edge running ahead and its trailing edge catching up, so it stretches toward the new place and gathers there, sideways in the bar and up and down in the sidebar. The sidebar folds to a rail: labels clip away first, the pill gathers into a circle, headers fold into short rules.