Week 08

Buttons

Nov 9, 2026 buttons system emphasis button group research spec tone

Deliverables

Three sets of buttons: Line, precise, Week, electric, and Make, soft. Line and Week are each one prototype: the buttons in use, at three levels of emphasis, switching between icon and text, text and icon, with a single-select button group; pressed, each button opens more to press, two or three levels deep; then every configuration laid out in enabled, hover, pressed and disabled, the depth step by step, and the spec. Make is smaller: a button you shape yourself, then see at three levels of emphasis in every state.

Set 1Line

Prototypes

In use, every state and the depth Lineworks, a blueprint archive: pick a building, zoom in, download the sheet. A blueprint draws a building before it exists, so here a line shows what will happen before it happens: point at an option and its result appears on the sheet dashed; press, and it is drawn solid. Emphasis is the amount of line: Download has two lines, Blueprints one, Zoom only crop marks. Each opens its options under itself, two or three levels deep; View is the single-select group. Below: every state, the depth, the spec.

Process

Set 1 started as Melt, a liquid idea, and ended as Line, made of nothing but outlines, set in a blueprint archive where a line shows what will happen. Every stage is here, the dropped one too, with why each changed.

1 · Melt, a sketch in Ideation

Melt sketch at rest
After a reference of an animated Contact me button whose cursor melts into it.
Melt sketch, Contact me filled
Pointed at, Contact me filled with cream.
Melt sketch, Résumé underlined
Résumé underlined itself.

Picked from the nineteen sketches to become Set 1.

2 · The drop

The drop trailing the pointer
The pointer carried a cream drop. At first it trailed behind like a ball and jumped left when it shrank.
The drop meeting Contact me
It came to sit right under the pointer, and the button’s edge reached out to meet it.

Three passes to make it behave: a pointer dot that stays visible on cream, cream and the dark pill that never mix, no jump.

3 · Melt, the prototype

Melt at rest
A designer’s contact card in cream on black.
Melt with Contact me full
Pointed at: Contact me full of cream.
Contact me opened two rows deep
Pressed, options dripped out as drops that landed as buttons.
Portfolio opened two rows deep
Two or three levels deep.

Depth came in: every button opens more to press.

4 · Melt, a tank of liquid · dropped

Contact me half full of sloshing cream
Contact me held liquid that rose halfway and sloshed as you moved.
Portfolio opened
Portfolio swelled out toward the pointer.

Dropped: the middle button reached for the pointer and felt far too twitchy, and liquid had been used enough. Melt moved to Ideation.

5 · Line, on a wire

Line at rest
Outlines only: two lines, one faint line, brackets.
Line pointed at
Pointed at: closed into one, drawn round by a pen, brackets closed.
Options on a branching wire
Options hung on a wire drawn down out of the button.

Emphasis became the amount of line, and nothing follows the pointer any more. The wire was one line too many: the buttons are already lines.

6 · Line, no wire

Options right under the button
Options open just under their button, sideways from their centre.

Closer, but the options still appeared as a flat surface opening, not as lines.

7 · Line, drawn line first

Option outlines being drawn
Each option’s outline is drawn from its top centre both ways round, then its words come in.

Fixed words that came in and then vanished; Résumé’s brackets now draw from opposite ends, the left from the top, the right from the bottom.

8 · Line, on a contact card

Line at rest
At rest.
Line pointed at
Pointed at.
Portfolio opened two rows deep
Portfolio → Case studies → three projects.

9 · Lineworks, a blueprint archive

The lines worked but the story did not: a contact card gives no reason for emphasis to be told by line weight. On an architect’s drawing it already is (cut walls heavy, edges medium, notes thin). So the buttons moved into a place where that is true, and the place answers them: an office’s archive of blueprints, where you change the building, zoom in and download. The brackets became crop marks that frame the zoom; the black page became blueprint paper.

The archive at rest
At rest: the toolbar over the sheet, the title strip on the right.
Blueprints opened two rows deep
Blueprints → a building → its floors.
Crop marks framing the zoom
Zoom: crop marks frame what will fill the sheet.
The sheet at 200%
Then open out with it. The sheet can be dragged.
The plotter line running down the sheet
Download: a plotter line runs down the sheet.
Section view with the file listed
The file is listed in the title strip; View switches to section.

10 · Height, dropped

The buttons felt one-dimensional. That was read as flat, so each button was drawn as a plate standing on the sheet, its height in line. It answered the wrong question: what was thin was the thinking, not the shape. Dropped. One thing was kept from this step: an option’s line is drawn before its fill, so no empty space arrives ahead of the line.

Buttons at rest with drawn height
At rest: Download stood a little.
Download pointed at
Pointed at: it rose.
Download pressed
Pressed: pushed flat.

11 · Now: a line shows what will happen

The meaning behind the line: a blueprint is a building drawn before it exists, so a line here shows what will happen before it happens. Pointed at, an option draws its result on the sheet dashed, as a proposal; pressed, it is drawn solid. The tools also moved off the drawing into a column on its right, in the order they are used, because options opening over the blueprint read as a collision.

The archive with the tools in a column
The tools in a column beside the sheet.
Another building dashed over the sheet
Pointed at Mapo Library: its walls, dashed, over the sheet.
A dashed frame where the zoom will land
Pointed at 2×: the part that would fill the sheet.
A dashed frame and a dashed file
Pointed at A3: the paper it takes, and the file, dashed.
The frame solid while the plotter runs
Pressed: the frame is solid while the plotter runs.
The section dashed before it is picked
Pointed at Section: the other view, dashed.
Set 2Week

Prototypes

In use, every state and the depth Tidelight, a fictional music festival week, restyled after Tron: black, drawn in lines of light, cyan for the system and orange for what is yours. Every button is a ring of light that a streak races round when pointed at. The dates are the single-select group; a date opens its day, and a set opens its details (three levels). Inside: weather, stage chips, a save star, a split ticket, and an X that derezzes the day. Below: every state, the depth, the spec.

Process

Set 2 changed concept five times before it found a scene that was mine. Every stage is here, the dropped ones too, with why each was left.

1 · Drain, playful · dropped

Drain at rest: a meal planner in coral on blue
A meal planner. Colour drained round each button like a clock wipe.
Drain opened
Pressed, the options came out below.

The first Set 2. The drain was still a liquid idea, after a week of liquid in Melt, so it was set aside for something fresher.

2 · Coin, Disc and Festival · sketches, dropped

Coin sketch
Coin: drop a coin in the slot to play.
Disc sketch
Disc: a big red disc, turning slowly like a record.
Disc opened
Disc opened into Listen, Play, Details.
Festival sketch
Festival: a speaker stack on one 124 bpm beat.

Two ideas of my own tried as sketches. The coin felt like a toy, the disc grew out of it, and the festival beat was loud for a button set. All three stay in Ideation; the festival came back later as the storyline.

3 · Flap, a split-flap board · dropped

Flap
The meal planner again, now mechanical: panels flipping on hinges like a station board.

Fresh motion and no liquid, but a station board had nothing to do with dinner.

4 · Flap, music · dropped

Flap as a music app
The same flips moved to a track in a music app.

The scene changed but the buttons did not: the concept and the buttons were not talking to each other.

5 · Wave · dropped

Wave at rest
Buttons built from the track’s own waveform.
Wave opened
Save recorded the waveform into itself; quality was the wave at three resolutions.

Closer: the motion came from the music. Still a scene I had invented, so it moved to Ideation for one from a reference of my own.

6 · Week, from my reference · kept

Week, white, at rest
A week on a white card after my reference GIF: seven dates under a big day name.
Week, white, opened
Each date a button: it opens the day’s weather and plans; a plan opens to a link.

The scene came first and each button does one plain thing in it. Motion slowed twice, and the day name now pushes down instead of crossfading.

7 · Coral on blue

Week in coral on blue
The colours of the music screen laid over the calendar.

Coral rows on blue turned mauve, so rows became faint white.

8 · A festival week, metal outlines

Week as a festival week with metallic outlines
The plans became a festival’s sets; every button got a thin chrome outline; corners went small.

The storyline gave the buttons a reason: sets, stages, passes.

9 · More kinds of button

Week with stage chips, save stars and a split ticket
Stage chips (multi-select), a save star on each set, a split ticket, an X alone.
The pass menu open
The split ticket’s pass menu.

The set needed more than one kind of button in each level, so toggles, a multi-select group and a split button joined.

10 · Tron

Week restyled after Tron
Black, chamfered lines of cyan light, orange for what is yours.

After the Tron references: light is the one material, so motion is light behaving like light: streaks, a light-cycle trail, a flicker on, a derez off.

11 · Now

The week at rest
The week, Sunday picked; the dots are gone.
Monday open with the forecast showing
The sun turns round its own centre.
A set opened to its link
Sets are lit panels; the chevrons run like an escalator; the star stands alone.

Small fixes from use: the date dots and the star’s frame went, a readable Opening… state on the ticket, light in the rows.

Set 3Make

Prototypes

Make it, then every state A button you make yourself. It starts as a rectangle of frosted glass with a blue light inside, soft as clay: press anywhere and pull, and the glass near your hand stretches or dents; let go and it keeps the shape. Type its label. Then make it a button, and it answers like one: pointed at, the light rises; held, it sinks; turned off, it goes out. Emphasis is how much light the glass holds. Below: your button in every state, and the spec.

Brief

Two sets of buttons, each expressing a tone. Tones can repeat. Every design has to do its job. Each one gets a drawing and a working prototype.

Tone is the soft attribute: the personality, the associations, the attitude. Function is the hard one: what the button is for and what it lets you do. A button's function is to say plainly that something will happen when you press it, and how much that thing matters next to the buttons around it. So the tone has to live in the shape, the fill and the way the button answers the pointer, while the order of importance still reads at a glance.

The rule that shapes everything: at least three button styles, each a different level of emphasis, built on one structure.

Three levels of emphasis

LevelThe brief's example
PrimaryA background fill colour
SecondaryA lower-contrast colour
TertiaryA transparent fill with an outline

What the structure has to take

PartHas to support
Icon and textAn icon with its label
Text onlyA label alone
Icon onlyAn icon alone
Button groupA row of buttons where one is picked at a time (single selection)

States

Shows
EnabledThe button at rest, ready to press
HoverThe button under the pointer, about to be pressed
PressedThe press landing
DisabledThe button is there but can't be pressed right now

The brief shows two drawings. Apple's: a dark alert with a short title and a one-sentence message, then three full-width capsules stacked: a blue filled Primary, a grey Destructive with red text, and a grey Secondary with white text. Material's: a phone with two travel cards. The first card ends in a filled View entry button beside a text-only Related articles; over the second floats an extended action button, a pencil icon with Add entry.

The spec

As before, no Figma file: every prototype carries its own spec in a section of the page. At least spacing, font, font size and line height, the size of each button, and every other property that shapes it: roundness, stroke width, icon size, the state layers, the disabled look, how the button group joins. The numbers are read from the values the prototype runs on, so the spec cannot drift from the design.

Research

What a button is and how it behaves, from Apple's Buttons and Material 3's All buttons. Nothing about tone yet, only the button.

The parts

One container and what it holds. The emphasis comes from the container alone: fill, tint, outline or nothing.

Add entry Related 1618824 40 1 2 3 4 5 radius 20 (full) · label 14 / 20, weight 500 outline 1
  1. ContainerFill, tint, outline or nothing; this is what sets the emphasis
  2. IconOptional; before the label, 18 in a 40 button
  3. LabelA short verb; the one thing the button does
  4. State layerCovers the button on hover and press, in the label's colour
  5. OutlineOnly on the outlined style; gives a transparent button an edge

The emphasis ladder

Material names five common buttons, Apple four styles. They line up as one ladder: the more the container fills, the louder the button. Use the loudest only once per view.

Filled · primary

The one action the view is for: save, send, continue. Apple: Prominent.

Tonal · secondary

A softer fill for the action next in line. Apple: Bordered, a grey or tinted capsule.

Outlined · tertiary

Transparent with an edge: important, but not the main move. Material only.

Text · lowest

No container until hovered; for the many small actions in cards and dialogs. Apple: Borderless.

Destructive is a colour

Not a level: any style with a red label. In Apple's alert it is a grey capsule, not the blue one.

Same build, same size

Only the container changes; height, padding and label stay, so levels can sit side by side.

One build, every button

What a button holds is a choice apart from its emphasis. Mixing the two gives every button the brief asks for, from one build.

Icon and text

The icon leads; less padding on the icon side (16 against 24) so the pair looks centred.

Text only

The default. Even padding on both sides; the label sets the width.

Icon only

A square (or circle) as tall as the others. It still needs a name: a tooltip and an accessible label.

Button group, single selection

Joined buttons for one choice: picking one unpicks the last. Material: connected button group; Apple: segmented control.

Try it

Plain buttons with no tone, doing everything the brief asks. Change what they hold, turn them off, then point at one and press it. In the group, Tab lands once; the arrow keys move the pick.

Three levels of emphasis

Button group, single selection

Buttons
Actions
  • ↵Enter or SpacePresses the focused button
  • ←ArrowsMove the pick along the group; Tab leaves it
  • ⊘DisabledGreyed and skipped by Tab; it can't be pressed

Four states

Hover and press lay a thin layer of the label's colour over the button; disabled drains the colour out of both container and label. Focus, from the keyboard, is a ring on top of any of them.

EnabledAt rest
HoverLayer about 8%
PressedLayer about 10–12%, the action runs
DisabledContainer 12%, label 38%

Numbers to remember

40Height of Material's common button; the label is 14 on a 20 line, weight 500.
48 · 44ptSmallest touch target, Material / Apple; a smaller button keeps a larger hit area.
24 · 16 · 8Side padding; padding on the icon side; gap between icon and label.
8 · 10 · 38%Hover layer, pressed layer, and a disabled label's opacity.

Do and don't

DoGive a view one primary button; let everything else step down.
DoMark a destructive action by colour and wording (Delete, not OK), and never make it the default.
DoGive an icon-only button a name the pointer and the screen reader can both find.
Don'tPut two filled buttons side by side; the eye can't tell which one matters.
Don'tLeave a disabled button unexplained; say nearby what turns it on.
Don'tUse a single-select group for actions; it holds a choice that stays picked, not commands.

Process

Ideation

Loose sketches, each running live in its box, each from a reference (Chrome, Classy, Shadow, 3D, Glow and Ember come from one board of six finishes; Melt, Line, Drain, Flood and Grow follow the motion of animated references), with every part the brief asks for: three levels of emphasis, a single-select group, and a switch at the bottom right that changes the buttons to icon and text, text or icon, and turns them off. Within a sketch every button has a motion of its own, for hover, press and let-go, not one shared press.

Haze Pills of out-of-focus colour on black. Get Started gathers its colour to the pointer, pulls it in under a press and blooms; Watch demo is smoke you wipe clear, rippling from its play mark; Read the docs turns its rim of colour and turns a page. The haze pours between group options.
Lens Glass in the corner of a dark panel, its corners bending with the panel’s. Create is a gel with a light inside that squashes and wobbles; Preview is clear glass that fogs like breath and blinks; Discard is a rim lit near the pointer that shakes its head.
Kit Flat web buttons on navy, the icon as its own part: the circle slides in to meet its pill, the lime block presses onto its hard shadow, the outline fills from below, the link draws its line. Crisp, no bounce; icon only turns the outline into a hexagon.
Chrome Polished metal capsules on a night-violet floor. Explore’s gloss slides down as its glow shrinks and a glint runs on release; Download’s arrow dives as chrome fills it from below; a point of light runs round Read more’s rim and its arrow stretches like wire.
Classy Ink and a soft serif on pale grey, no springs: everything moves like a pen. The words turn over into italic; Reserve is inked across like a blotter; Learn more’s outline is drawn again and thickens under a press; the pick moves like a stroke.
Shadow Lavender pills floating over lavender; all about height. Read more rises and lands; Save is a glass sheet that tilts toward the pointer; Share drops onto its own shadow; the pick lifts off the track while it travels.
3D Indigo keys in thick black rims, each a mechanism: Download is a plunger that sinks into its rim, Upload a rocker that tips toward the half you press, Cancel a rubber ring that boings; the pick hops between slots.
Glow Light on near-black. Start Now’s blue-to-copper gradient leans after the pointer and rings out on release; Join is a lamp that breathes and lights from the middle; Learn’s line flows with colour and its label blooms; the pick takes its colour from where it stands.
Ember Copper on warm blush; heat is the material. Buy now’s flame flickers, flares as its knob slides, and throws sparks; warmth gathers under the pointer on Add to cart; a spark runs round Details like a fuse; the pick leaves a trail of sparks.
Inlay White slabs with copper edges set into a matte grey surface; emphasis is height. Continue is a plunger, Save a rocker that tips under your finger, and Skip has no slab until a press raises one to meet you. The group’s slab drops, slides and stands up again.
Tab Dark profile pills with a blue rounded-square key. Follow’s glow breathes, is sucked in and bursts into Following; the profile’s key slides the length of the pill and turns its chevron up; Share’s key pops up over its corner; the key hops between group options.
Ticker A soft cream slab whose words run past its edge. Its sentence runs through like a ticker on hover and the bevel turns inside out under a press; Save’s letters roll over in a wave; Details loosens its letters and rounds its corners; the pick’s word gains weight as the slab arrives.
Melt The pointer carries a cream drop on black, in one liquid layer with everything cream. Contact me’s edge reaches out to meet it, the two run together, and the cream rises from where it came in and drains out where it leaves; the drop sinks into Portfolio and beads on its lower edge; it sinks into Résumé’s underline; the pick necks and pulls across.
Focus Thick white pills with a shallow depth of field. Select sharpens and rises as the pointer nears and blurs back under a press; Filter’s frosted glass thickens; Compare is seen double until you settle on it; focus pulls from option to option.
Line Thin strokes on deep navy that turn into each other. Play draws its ring and becomes Pause; Menu’s three lines gather into an arrow; Back’s head comes apart and closes; the zoom pick is a ring that undraws round the old option and draws round the new.
Drain Coral on flat blue. Add is a disc that drains round like a clock hand to an outline and minus, and fills back round to a plus; a solid bar wipes across Save; Skip’s dot runs out into a line; group rings drain and fill a beat apart.
Dock A light dock of soft grey tiles. New squashes and pops a note out; Notes fans its stacked papers; the gear turns a notch on a spring. The dock swells under the pointer, the nearest tile most, and the picked tile bounces twice as the dot slides under it.
Flood A cream pill with an acid-lime dot on near-black. The dot floods the pill and becomes an arrow, then runs back; on Join the dot runs to the front and the words step aside; Read’s dot drops into a line; the group’s dot leaps in an arc.
Grow A studio’s row of black blocks on mint. The client block grows out both ways into its list of work and folds back; About’s grey words whiten as the block breathes wider; a shutter drops inside Contact; a white bar slides under the picked section.
Disc A large red disc follows the pointer, turning over slowly and heavily, like a record on its edge, and keeps turning a moment after you stop. Bring it to the ring in the middle and it slows, comes to rest face up and opens into a red Play pill; two small discs roll out from behind it and unroll into an outlined Listen and a plain Details. Move away and it all rolls back in.
Festival The buttons are a speaker stack at a festival, all on one 124 bpm clock: Get tickets is the subwoofer, thumping and sending out a ring on every beat (pressed, the drop shakes the stage); Lineup buzzes on the offbeats; Map’s outline shimmers on the sixteenths; the picked day’s level bars dance. Sound can be turned on.
Melt (was Set 1) Cream on black: the pointer carries a cream drop and every button is made of the same liquid. Contact me fills and sloshes, Portfolio swells toward the pointer, Résumé draws its outline from where the drop touched; options drip out as drops. Replaced by Line: the pointer-tracking felt too twitchy, and liquid had been used enough.
Wave Was Set 2 for a while (after Drain and Flap): a track in a music app built from its own waveform. Add to playlist plays a few bars, Save records the waveform into itself, Skip fast-forwards a strip of tape, quality is the waveform at three resolutions.